Do you have obligations to people in other countries—or just to your fellow citizens?
💭 How to Think About This
Climate change, pandemics, and global supply chains don't respect borders. But we vote in national elections and pay national taxes. What do we owe people in other countries? Is there such a thing as "global citizenship"?
Do you have obligations to people in other countries?
🔒 Start writing to unlock hints
Arguments for global obligations: • Human rights apply to ALL humans • Suffering matters regardless of nationality • "Moral luck" of birth shouldn't determine fate • All people have equal moral worth • Borders are arbitrary historical accidents Why should a line on a map determine obligations?
We're already connected: • Our consumption affects others • Climate emissions harm everyone • Supply chains cross borders • Wealth of rich nations partly from global systems • Pandemics spread everywhere We're not separate—we're interconnected.
Problems that require cooperation: • Climate change (everyone's atmosphere) • Pandemics (viruses don't need passports) • Nuclear weapons (affects all) • Refugee crises (caused by global forces) • Economic crises (interconnected markets) National solutions to global problems fail.
Being a global citizen: • Be informed about global issues • Consider global impact of consumption • Support international cooperation • Engage with people from other cultures • Advocate for global justice Vote nationally; live globally.
We have obligations to all humans—borders are arbitrary, and we're deeply interconnected through global systems.
Key insight: Human rights apply universally. Our consumption, emissions, and economies affect people everywhere. Global problems require global cooperation. Vote nationally, but recognize moral ties beyond borders.
Layered obligations: • Strongest: family and close community • Strong: fellow citizens • Some: all humans • Obligations diminish with distance • Special ties create special duties • But distant strangers still matter somewhat Not equal, but not zero.
Why national ties are special: • We share democratic institutions • We voted for shared obligations • Social contracts are national • Accountability is possible nationally • We can't vote on global policy Special duties to fellow citizens are real.
Global obligations still exist: • Don't harm others abroad • Help with dire emergencies • Support fair international rules • Reduce global harms we cause • Basic human rights are universal Prioritize nation, but don't ignore world.
The moderate position: • Neither pure cosmopolitanism nor pure nationalism • Context determines relative weight • Some global issues are urgent • Some national priorities are legitimate • Negotiate case by case Hold multiple loyalties simultaneously.
We have some obligations to everyone, but stronger obligations to fellow citizens—concentric circles of moral duty.
Key insight: Special ties (family, nation) create special duties, but distant strangers still matter. We shouldn't harm others abroad, should help in emergencies, and support fair global rules. Neither pure cosmopolitan nor pure nationalist.
Why nation comes first: • We share history, culture, institutions • Democratic accountability is national • We voted for mutual obligations • Social contracts are with citizens • Resources are limited—help our own first • Charity begins at home Take care of your own.
Issues with "global citizenship": • Who votes on global policy? No one • Unaccountable global elites decide • Dilutes meaningful citizenship • Can't have loyalty to everyone • "World citizen" often means citizen of nowhere • Globalism benefits the rich Real citizenship is local and national.
Legitimate national priorities: • Economic interests of citizens • Border security • Cultural preservation • National security • Jobs for our people first • These aren't selfish—they're democratic Leaders serve their voters, not the world.
Counter-arguments: • Some problems ARE global (climate) • Interconnection is real • Pure isolation isn't possible • National interest includes cooperation • "America First" still needs allies Prioritizing nation doesn't mean ignoring world entirely.
Our primary obligations are to fellow citizens—that's what democratic citizenship means. Take care of our own first.
Key insight: Real citizenship is national. Global institutions lack democratic accountability. Leaders serve their voters. But even national interest requires some international cooperation—pure isolation isn't possible.
🔄 Other Perspectives
🟢 "Yes, We're All Human"
Human rights apply universally. Borders are arbitrary. We're interconnected through global systems. Our consumption and emissions affect everyone. Vote nationally, but recognize moral ties beyond borders.
🟡 "Some, Not Equal"
Concentric circles of obligation—strongest to family and nation, but some duty to all humans. Don't harm others abroad, help in emergencies, support fair global rules. Neither pure cosmopolitan nor pure nationalist.
🔴 "Nation First"
Real citizenship is national. We share institutions and social contracts with fellow citizens. Global institutions lack accountability. But even national interest requires some cooperation—isolation isn't possible.
My coffee: grown in Colombia, shipped through Panama, roasted in Italy, sold by American company. My phone: designed in California, parts from China, assembled in Vietnam. I vote in one country. I live in the global economy. Problems and opportunities don't stop at borders. Neither should awareness.
See more guidance →
Key concepts: Global citizenship, cosmopolitanism, international cooperation, global commons, nationalism vs. globalism.