Resolve reviewer comments

I need to close out reviewer comments on the product roadmap deck. Resolve all reviewer threads assigned to me, accept or reject the related changes, update any slides that need one-sentence clarification, and mark unresolved items for the product lead. Finish this and send the cleared deck to Nina by Tuesday morning.

Before I resolve reviewer comments, surface the risky items: list comments that request scope changes, highlight comments from procurement or legal that block approval, and extract any reviewer questions left unanswered. Flag comments that, if closed without action, will cause pushback in the approval meeting.

I marked a thread resolved after a quick wording change, and Maya reopened it saying I ignored substantive concerns. I didn’t want to escalate before Friday’s sign-off. What did I overlook in my resolution approach, and how should I repair the situation so she trusts the change and we still meet the deadline?

We keep re-opening supposedly resolved reviewer comments late in the process and it costs us credibility. Which habit will stop this — stricter acceptance criteria for marking resolved, a single reviewer triage meeting, or documenting rationale on the comment — and which one will actually restore reviewer trust fastest?