Provide proof of delivery

Provide proof of delivery for a parcel sold to Natasha Brown on June 3 for $95. Gather the tracking number showing delivered on June 8, a photograph of the package at the doorstep, the delivery confirmation email sent to Natasha, and the signed delivery receipt from the carrier. Compile these into one PDF and submit it to the case along with a two-sentence timeline: shipped June 4, delivered June 8, customer notified June 8.

Before I upload proof of delivery for Natasha Brown, organize it for quick reviewer reading: put the $95, June 3 order, and 'delivered June 8' line first, then show the tracking delivery scan, the doorstep photo, and the carrier's signed receipt. Highlight any differences—like delivery to 'front porch' vs 'reception'—that might cause confusion and note how I notified Natasha after delivery.

Natasha Brown says she never received the package even though tracking shows delivered June 8 and I have a doorstep photo. I worry a reviewer will still side with her. What specific combination of evidence (signed receipt, timestamped photo metadata, notification messages) gives the best chance to close this in my favor, and what objections should I anticipate?

My shop keeps getting disputes where tracking shows delivery and I even have photos, yet buyers claim non-receipt. This eats returns and time. Where is my delivery proof failing on credibility, and what single habit—better photo metadata, requiring signature on delivery, or immediate SMS notification—will most reliably stop these disputes?