Overview
Every living animal responds to the world around it. A dog wags its tail when its owner returns, a honeybee dances on the comb to tell its sisters where the flowers are, a newly hatched duckling follows the first moving thing it sees, and a weaver bird builds an elaborate hanging nest without ever having been taught. All of these are examples of behaviour, the way an organism acts in response to its internal state and its external environment. The scientific study of animal behaviour is called ethology, and this chapter introduces its main ideas as they appear in the Class 9 Biology course of the Andhra Pradesh State Board. We begin by asking what behaviour is and how scientists observe it, then divide behaviour into innate (inborn) and learned (acquired) types. Under innate behaviour we study reflexes, instincts and taxes; under learned behaviour we study imprinting, conditioning, habituation, trial-and-error learning and insight learning, with the classic experiments of Pavlov, Lorenz, Kohler and von Frisch. We then look at social behaviour, communication, courtship and territory, migration and parental care, and finally at the biological basis of behaviour, hormones, the nervous system and the influence of environment, ending with a note on human behaviour. Understanding behaviour helps us handle animals with care, protect wildlife, and understand ourselves better.
Learning Objectives
- Define behaviour and ethology and describe how ethologists observe animals in natural conditions.
- Distinguish innate behaviour from learned behaviour with examples from everyday life.
- Explain reflex action, instinct and taxis as forms of inborn behaviour.
- Describe imprinting and Konrad Lorenz's experiments with greylag geese.
- Explain classical conditioning through Pavlov's experiment on dogs and give examples of habituation and trial-and-error learning.
- Describe insight learning using Kohler's experiment with chimpanzees.
- Explain social behaviour and communication in honeybees, including the round dance and the waggle dance.
- Describe courtship, territorial behaviour, migration and parental care in animals with examples.
- Relate behaviour to hormones, the nervous system and the environment, and compare animal behaviour with human behaviour.
Topics in this chapter
17 topics · tap a topic title to jump straight to it.
What is behaviour? The science of ethology
Behaviour is everything an animal does in response to a change inside its body or in its surroundings. When you touch a snail and it withdraws into its shell, when a cat arches its back at a strange dog, when a mother hen gathers her chicks under her wings at dusk, when a cow walks to the shed at milking time, all of these are behaviour. Behaviour includes movements, sounds, postures, colour changes, feeding, fighting, mating and nest building. Even standing still and freezing when a hawk passes overhead is behaviour.
Behaviour always has two parts. There is a stimulus, the change that the animal detects with its sense organs, and a response, the action the animal makes. Light, sound, smell, touch, temperature, hunger, thirst and the presence of another animal are all stimuli. The nervous system receives the stimulus, processes it and sends orders to muscles and glands, which produce the response.
The scientific study of animal behaviour is called ethology (from the Greek ethos, meaning character or habit). Ethologists prefer to watch animals in their natural surroundings rather than only in laboratory cages, because a caged animal often behaves very differently from a free one. The founders of modern ethology, Konrad Lorenz, Niko Tinbergen and Karl von Frisch, shared the Nobel Prize in 1973 for their discoveries about how animals organise their individual and social behaviour. Lorenz studied imprinting in geese, Tinbergen studied the instinctive pecking of herring gull chicks and the behaviour of the stickleback fish, and von Frisch decoded the dance language of honeybees.
Why should a student of biology study behaviour? First, behaviour is the animal's chief tool for survival: finding food, escaping enemies, finding a mate and raising young are all achieved through behaviour. Second, behaviour is inherited and evolves like any other character, so studying it tells us about evolution. Third, understanding behaviour helps us in practical ways: in rearing cattle, poultry and fish, in controlling pests, in conserving wildlife, and in training animals such as dogs and elephants. Finally, human beings are animals too, and much of what we learn from animals helps psychologists understand human learning and emotion.
Ethologists ask four questions about any behaviour, which Tinbergen formulated: What causes it right now (mechanism)? How does it develop during the animal's life? What is its survival value? How did it evolve? Throughout this chapter, keep these questions in mind whenever you meet a new example.
- A dog salivating when it smells food: the smell is the stimulus and salivation is the response.
- A sunflower head turning towards the sun is a response in a plant, but ethology restricts itself to animals, where responses involve a nervous system.
- Watching a squirrel in a park bury nuts in autumn is ethology in the field; measuring how quickly a rat learns a maze is ethology in the laboratory.
- Behaviour = response of an organism to a stimulus, coordinated by the nervous system and hormones.
- Ethology = the scientific study of animal behaviour, especially under natural conditions.
How ethologists study behaviour: observation and experiment
The first tool of the ethologist is patient observation. Jane Goodall sat quietly for months in the forests of Tanzania before chimpanzees allowed her near enough to see them using grass stems to fish termites out of mounds, the first record of tool use by a non-human animal. Salim Ali, the birdman of India, spent decades watching birds in the field and writing down what he saw. Good observation means recording exactly what the animal does, at what time, in what weather and in whose company, without adding what we imagine it feels.
Ethologists keep an ethogram, a catalogue of all the distinct actions an animal performs, such as feeding, grooming, threat display, submissive posture, calling and nest building. They note how often each action occurs and what happens just before and just after. From such records patterns emerge: for example, that a male fantail flycatcher sings most in the early morning during the breeding season.
The second tool is experiment. The ethologist changes one thing and sees whether behaviour changes. Tinbergen noticed that a herring gull chick pecks at the red spot on its parent's yellow beak to make the parent regurgitate food. He offered chicks cardboard models: a yellow beak with a red spot, a beak with no spot, a beak with a black spot, and even a plain red stick with white bands. The chicks pecked most at models with a red spot, and even more at the striped stick, showing that the chick responds to a simple sign stimulus (a red contrasting spot on a thin object) rather than to the whole parent. Such simple triggers of innate behaviour are called sign stimuli or releasers.
Tinbergen also studied the three-spined stickleback fish. In the breeding season the male develops a red belly and attacks any other red-bellied male entering its territory. Crude wooden models with a red underside were attacked fiercely, while a perfect model of a stickleback without red was ignored. Again a single feature, the red belly, was the releaser.
A third tool is comparison between species and between wild and captive animals, and a fourth is the study of development: does a chick reared alone in silence still sing its species' song? Such deprivation experiments separate what is inborn from what is learned.
Modern ethologists also use radio collars, camera traps, sound recorders and satellite tags. Tags on olive ridley turtles nesting on the Odisha coast have shown how far they travel across the Bay of Bengal. But every technique still rests on the old habit of watching carefully and asking why.
- Tinbergen's cardboard-beak experiment showed that a herring gull chick responds to a red spot, not to the whole parent.
- A male stickleback attacks a crude red-bellied model but ignores a lifelike model without red: the red belly is the sign stimulus.
- Jane Goodall's long observation of chimpanzees revealed tool use, which no short visit would have found.
- Sign stimulus (releaser) = a simple feature of the environment that triggers a fixed inborn response.
Innate behaviour: inborn responses
Behaviour that an animal shows correctly the very first time, without any practice or teaching, is called innate behaviour or inborn behaviour. It is written in the animal's genes and appears in every normal member of the species in the same form. A spider spins its web perfectly without ever seeing another spider do it. A cuckoo chick, hatched in a crow's nest and never meeting its parents, still pushes the crow's eggs out of the nest, grows up and later sings the cuckoo's call. A newborn human baby turns its head towards a touch on the cheek and sucks: the rooting and sucking reflexes.
Innate behaviour has four properties. It is inherited, passed from parents through genes. It is stereotyped, performed the same way each time by every individual. It is species specific, so every weaver bird builds the weaver-bird type of nest and no other. And it is present without learning, appearing complete at the first opportunity even in an animal reared in isolation.
Ethologists recognise three main categories of innate behaviour. A reflex is a simple, quick, automatic response of a part of the body to a stimulus, such as blinking when something approaches the eye. A taxis (plural taxes) is a movement of the whole animal towards or away from a stimulus: moths flying towards a lamp show positive phototaxis, cockroaches running from light show negative phototaxis, and earthworms moving away from dry air show negative hydrotaxis. An instinct is a complex chain of actions, such as nest building, courtship or migration, that is inborn but takes time to complete and often depends on the animal's internal state, for example the breeding season.
Innate behaviour has great value for animals with short lives or no parental care. An insect that lives for a few weeks has no time to learn how to find a mate or lay eggs on the correct plant; it must know at birth. The disadvantage is rigidity. A sphex wasp drags a paralysed cricket to its burrow, leaves it at the entrance, goes in to inspect the burrow, comes out and pulls the cricket in. If an experimenter moves the cricket a few centimetres while the wasp is inside, the wasp brings it back to the entrance and inspects the burrow all over again, and will repeat this dozens of times. It cannot skip a step because the whole chain is fixed.
Innate behaviour is not completely unchangeable. It can be modified a little by experience, and it can be triggered only when the animal is in the right condition. A hungry animal responds strongly to food stimuli; a well-fed one ignores them. This internal readiness is called motivation or drive.
- A newly hatched sea turtle crawls straight towards the brighter horizon of the sea without any guidance: innate positive phototaxis.
- A cuckoo reared by crows sings the cuckoo song: the song is inborn, not learned from foster parents.
- The sphex wasp repeating its burrow inspection every time the cricket is moved shows how rigid an instinct chain can be.
- Innate behaviour = inherited + stereotyped + species-specific + performed correctly without prior experience.
- Taxis = directed movement of the whole organism towards (positive) or away from (negative) a stimulus; phototaxis (light), chemotaxis (chemicals), geotaxis (gravity), hydrotaxis (moisture).
Reflex action: the simplest behaviour
A reflex action is an immediate, involuntary and automatic response to a stimulus, usually involving only one part of the body, and usually protective. If your finger touches a hot pan you pull your hand away before you have even felt the pain. If a speck of dust flies at your eye, you blink. If food enters the windpipe you cough. If a doctor taps the tendon just below your kneecap, your lower leg kicks forward: the knee-jerk reflex. Sneezing, yawning, salivating at the smell of food, the narrowing of the pupil in bright light, and the withdrawal of a sea anemone's tentacles when touched are all reflexes.
Reflexes are fast because the message does not travel all the way to the brain for a decision. The pathway, called a reflex arc, runs from the receptor to the spinal cord and straight back to the muscle. In the hot-pan example: heat receptors in the skin of the finger are stimulated; a sensory neuron carries the impulse to the spinal cord; there it passes through a short relay (inter) neuron; a motor neuron carries the impulse out to the muscles of the arm; the biceps contracts and the hand jerks away. Only afterwards does a separate message reach the brain and you feel the pain and say "ouch". Because of this the brain is left free for more complicated work, and vital protective responses do not depend on thought.
Reflexes can be simple or complex. The knee jerk is the simplest, using only two neurons. The withdrawal reflex uses three. Coughing and swallowing involve a whole sequence of muscles coordinated by the medulla of the brain stem, but they are still reflexes because they are involuntary and stereotyped.
Reflexes are innate, but in mammals they can become linked with new stimuli by learning, as Pavlov showed with salivation in dogs. Such a learned reflex is a conditioned reflex, in contrast to the inborn unconditioned reflex. Reflexes are also affected by the animal's state: a frightened animal jumps at a small sound, and a sleeping one hardly responds.
Reflexes matter to doctors as well as biologists. Testing the knee jerk, the pupil reflex and the plantar reflex (curling of the toes when the sole is stroked) tells a doctor whether the spinal cord and nerves are working. In a newborn baby, the presence of the sucking, grasping and startle reflexes shows that the nervous system is developing normally, and their disappearance at the right age shows that the brain is taking over control.
- Knee-jerk reflex: a tap below the kneecap stretches the thigh muscle tendon; a sensory neuron carries the impulse to the spinal cord, a motor neuron returns it, and the thigh muscle contracts, kicking the leg.
- Withdrawal reflex: the hand jerks away from a thorn in about 0.05 second, well before the pain is felt.
- Pupil reflex: in a torch beam the pupil shrinks in a fraction of a second to protect the retina.
- Reflex arc: Receptor → Sensory neuron → Spinal cord (relay neuron) → Motor neuron → Effector (muscle/gland).
- Reflex action = involuntary + rapid + automatic + usually protective + does not need the brain's decision.
Instinct: complex inborn behaviour patterns
An instinct is a complex, inborn pattern of behaviour made of many actions performed in a fixed sequence, usually to serve a major need of life: building a home, finding a mate, caring for young, or moving with the seasons. Unlike a reflex, which is a single quick act of one part of the body, an instinct may take hours or weeks, involves the whole animal, and is usually released only when the animal is in a suitable internal condition and meets the right sign stimulus.
The Baya weaver bird (Ploceus philippinus), common across Andhra Pradesh, is a fine example. At the start of the monsoon the male strips long blades from grass or palm leaves, flies to a branch overhanging water or a thorny tree, and weaves a hanging nest with a long entrance tube. He ties knots, weaves strips over and under, and shapes the chamber. A young male building for the first time produces the same design, though a little untidily; he does not learn it from a teacher. The female inspects the half-built nest and, if she accepts, the male completes it. Every step is inherited.
Other examples of instinct are the web spinning of spiders, the dam building of beavers, the comb building of honeybees (perfect hexagonal cells of wax), the tunnel digging of termites, and the elaborate courtship dances of peacocks and cranes. In mammals, a female rat builds a nest, licks her newborn, and retrieves any pup that strays, all correctly at her first litter.
Instincts often work as a chain in which each step provides the stimulus for the next. In the courtship of the stickleback, the male's zigzag dance releases the female's approach; her approach releases his leading her to the nest; her entry releases his nudging her tail; nudging releases her egg laying; the eggs release his fertilising them. Break the chain at any point and the sequence stops.
Instinct has both strengths and weaknesses. Its strength is reliability: no time or teacher is needed, and the behaviour is ready when the need arises. Its weakness is inflexibility: the animal cannot adjust when the situation is unusual. A hen that hears her chick peeping under a glass jar runs to rescue it, but if the jar is soundproof she ignores the same chick struggling in full view, because the sign stimulus is the sound, not the sight.
In animals with larger brains, instinct is increasingly mixed with learning. A young songbird inherits a rough template of its song but must hear adults to perfect it. Human beings have very few pure instincts; almost everything we do is shaped by learning on a foundation of a few inborn drives such as hunger, fear and the urge to communicate.
- The Baya weaver builds its knotted, tube-entranced nest correctly at the first attempt without instruction.
- Honeybees build hexagonal wax cells of nearly identical size in every hive in the world.
- A hen ignores a chick struggling silently under a soundproof jar but rushes to one it can hear: the releaser is the sound.
- Instinct = inherited, complex, species-specific chain of actions, released by a sign stimulus when the animal is in the right internal state.
Learned behaviour: an introduction
Learned behaviour is behaviour that changes as a result of the animal's experience. It is not present at birth in a complete form; it appears, improves or changes with practice, and it differs from one individual to another according to what each has experienced. A puppy is not born knowing its name, that the sound of a car means its owner is home, or that the kitchen is where food appears, but a few weeks of living in a house teach it all these things.
Learning requires a nervous system that can store information, in other words memory. The more developed the brain, especially the cerebrum, the greater the animal's capacity to learn. Earthworms and planarians can learn only very simple things; insects such as honeybees can learn the position of flowers and the colour of the hive entrance; birds and mammals learn a great deal; primates, dolphins, elephants and above all human beings learn most of what they do.
Learned behaviour has properties opposite to those of innate behaviour. It is acquired, not inherited, though the capacity to learn is inherited. It is variable, differing between individuals and changing over time. It is adaptable: the animal can adjust its behaviour to new situations, which is the great advantage over rigid instinct. And it takes time and practice, which is its cost: a young animal that must learn everything is helpless for a long period and needs parental protection, as human infants do.
Ethologists and psychologists recognise several types of learning, which we shall study one by one. Habituation is learning to ignore a repeated stimulus that brings neither reward nor harm. Imprinting is the rapid learning by a very young animal of what its parent (or its species) looks like, during a short sensitive period. Conditioning is the learning of an association between a stimulus and a response (classical conditioning) or between an action and its consequence (operant conditioning). Trial-and-error learning is learning by trying different actions and repeating the ones that succeed. Insight learning is solving a new problem by understanding the situation, without trial and error. Imitation is learning by copying another animal.
In real life innate and learned behaviour are woven together. A kitten is born with the instinct to pounce, but it learns by playing with its mother's tail and with its litter mates exactly how to pounce on a mouse. A honeyguide bird instinctively leads a human or a honey badger to a bee's nest, but it learns which people follow it. The dividing line is a matter of degree. What every student should remember is that learning gives an animal a second inheritance, the inheritance of experience, on top of the inheritance of genes.
- A puppy learning to come when its name is called is learned behaviour; wagging its tail when happy is innate.
- A crow in a city learning to drop walnuts on a road for cars to crack, then waiting for the traffic light, shows learning in a bird.
- Children learn their mother tongue, the most elaborate learned behaviour of any animal, but the urge to communicate is innate.
- Learned behaviour = acquired through experience + variable between individuals + modifiable + needs memory and practice.
Habituation and imprinting
Habituation is the simplest form of learning: an animal gradually stops responding to a stimulus that is repeated many times and turns out to be harmless and unrewarding. When you tap the water near a snail it withdraws into its shell; tap again and again, and after several taps it stops withdrawing. It has learned that the tap means nothing. Birds in a field are startled by a scarecrow on the first day, but within a week they perch on its hat, because the scarecrow never moves or harms them. People who move to a house beside a railway line stop noticing the trains. Habituation saves the animal from wasting energy and attention on meaningless stimuli, leaving it alert to the ones that matter. It is different from fatigue, because a new stimulus, or the same stimulus after a rest, brings the response back.
Imprinting is a special, rapid and lasting form of learning that occurs only during a short sensitive period early in life. The Austrian ethologist Konrad Lorenz studied it in greylag geese. Goslings normally follow their mother within hours of hatching. Lorenz divided a clutch of eggs; half hatched under the mother goose and followed her, and half hatched in an incubator and saw Lorenz first. These goslings followed Lorenz everywhere, walking behind him, swimming after him, and even ignoring their real mother when placed with her. When the two groups were mixed and then scattered, each group ran to its own "parent". The goslings had imprinted on the first large moving object they saw during the first day or two of life.
Imprinting has three special features. It happens only during the sensitive period (in ducks and geese roughly 13 to 16 hours after hatching, and never after about two days). It is very rapid, needing only a brief exposure. And it is practically irreversible: a bird imprinted on a human continues to prefer humans, and when adult may even try to court people rather than its own kind. Lorenz's goslings imprinted on his boots, and a famous photograph shows him striding across a meadow with a line of goslings behind him.
Imprinting has two survival values. Filial imprinting keeps a chick close to its mother, who protects it and leads it to food; a chick that followed any goose would be lost in a crowded colony. Sexual imprinting, in which the young bird learns what its own species looks like, ensures that it chooses a mate of the correct species when it grows up.
Imprinting is important in conservation. Whooping cranes and other endangered birds reared by humans have imprinted on their keepers and refused to breed with cranes; now keepers wear crane-shaped puppets and hide their faces while feeding chicks. Salmon imprint on the smell of the stream in which they hatched and return to it years later to spawn, an example of olfactory imprinting.
- A snail stops withdrawing after repeated harmless taps on the water: habituation.
- Lorenz's incubator-hatched goslings followed him instead of their mother and later preferred humans: imprinting on the first moving object seen.
- Salmon return to their home stream by its remembered smell: olfactory imprinting.
- Habituation = decrease in response to a repeated, harmless, unrewarded stimulus; response recovers after rest or a new stimulus.
- Imprinting = rapid, irreversible learning during a brief sensitive period early in life (first 1-2 days in geese and ducks).
Classical conditioning: Pavlov's experiment
Conditioning is learning by association. In classical conditioning an animal learns to give an inborn response to a new stimulus that was previously meaningless, because that stimulus has repeatedly occurred together with the natural stimulus. The Russian physiologist Ivan Pavlov discovered it around 1900 while studying digestion in dogs.
Pavlov fitted a small tube to a dog's cheek so that the saliva flowing from its salivary gland could be measured. When food (meat powder) was placed in the dog's mouth, saliva flowed: this is the natural, inborn reflex. Food is the unconditioned stimulus and salivation is the unconditioned response. Pavlov then rang a bell just before giving the food, and repeated this pairing many times. At first the bell alone produced no saliva. But after a number of pairings the dog salivated on hearing the bell, even when no food followed. The bell had become a conditioned stimulus, and salivation to the bell is the conditioned response or conditioned reflex. The dog had learned that the bell predicts food.
Pavlov went on to discover the rules of conditioning. Extinction: if the bell is rung many times without food, the conditioned response slowly fades. Spontaneous recovery: after a rest, the response to the bell partly returns. Generalisation: the dog salivates to a bell of a slightly different tone as well. Discrimination: if only one tone is followed by food and another is not, the dog learns to salivate only to the first. The timing also matters: the conditioned stimulus must come just before the unconditioned stimulus, not after it.
Classical conditioning is everywhere in daily life. Fish in a pond come to the surface when they hear the footsteps of the person who feeds them. Cattle walk to the shed when they hear the milking pail. A child who has had a painful injection cries on seeing a white coat. The sight of a lemon being cut makes your mouth water. Advertisers pair a product with pleasant music so that the product itself later gives a pleasant feeling.
Conditioning is the basis of much animal training. A dog is trained to sit by pairing the word "sit" with a gentle push and a reward; an elephant learns the mahout's commands; circus animals learn to respond to whistles. It also explains fears: a person bitten by a dog may fear all dogs for years, a conditioned fear that can be reduced by extinction, that is, by gradually meeting friendly dogs without harm.
Pavlov received the Nobel Prize in 1904 for his work on digestion, but it is his discovery of the conditioned reflex that made him famous, because it showed that learning could be studied by measurement, like any other process in physiology.
- Before conditioning: food → saliva; bell → nothing. During conditioning: bell + food → saliva, repeated. After conditioning: bell alone → saliva.
- Fish in a temple tank rising when they hear the priest's footsteps at feeding time.
- A child crying at the sight of a doctor's white coat after a painful injection: a conditioned fear.
- Unconditioned stimulus (food) → Unconditioned response (salivation) — inborn.
- Conditioned stimulus (bell) paired repeatedly with food → Conditioned response (salivation to bell) — learned.
- Extinction: repeated conditioned stimulus without reinforcement → conditioned response fades.
Trial-and-error learning and operant conditioning
In trial-and-error learning an animal facing a problem tries many different actions more or less at random; actions that fail are dropped, actions that succeed and bring a reward are repeated, and with practice the successful action is performed faster and more smoothly. The American psychologist Edward Thorndike studied this with cats placed in a "puzzle box" that could be opened by pulling a loop of string. A hungry cat, seeing food outside, scratched, pushed and bit at random until by chance it pulled the loop and escaped. On each repeated trial the cat took less time, until finally it pulled the string at once. Thorndike called this the law of effect: an action followed by a satisfying result is more likely to be repeated, and an action followed by discomfort is less likely.
B. F. Skinner refined this into operant conditioning using the Skinner box, in which a rat or pigeon receives a food pellet whenever it presses a lever or pecks a disc. The animal first presses the lever by accident, gets food, and soon presses it deliberately. The food is a reinforcement; a reward that strengthens behaviour is positive reinforcement, and the removal of something unpleasant (switching off a mild shock) is negative reinforcement. Punishment, an unpleasant result, weakens behaviour. The difference from Pavlov's classical conditioning is that in operant conditioning the animal's own action (the operant) produces the result, whereas in classical conditioning the response is a reflex triggered by a stimulus and the animal's action does not change what happens.
Trial-and-error learning is seen throughout the animal kingdom. A young toad snaps at a bee, is stung, and thereafter avoids anything with black and yellow stripes. A crow trying to open a walnut drops it from different heights until it finds the height that cracks the shell. A kitten learns which way to bat a ball to make it roll. A rat learns the path through a maze to reach food, making fewer wrong turns each time. A child learns to ride a bicycle by many falls, gradually keeping the actions that keep the cycle upright.
The speed of trial-and-error learning depends on the animal's brain, its motivation (a hungry rat learns a maze faster than a fed one), and how quickly the reward follows the action. A reward that comes immediately after the action is far more effective than one that comes minutes later, which is why dog trainers give a treat the instant the dog obeys.
Operant conditioning is the foundation of animal training in circuses, in guide dogs for the blind, in sniffer dogs at airports and in dolphin shows. In human life it explains why children repeat behaviour that earns praise and why habits are so hard to break: the habit was reinforced hundreds of times. Teachers use it, knowingly or not, every time they praise a correct answer.
- Thorndike's cat in the puzzle box: the time to escape fell from several minutes on the first trial to a few seconds after twenty trials.
- A rat in a Skinner box presses a lever by chance, receives food, and within an hour presses it steadily whenever hungry.
- A toad that has been stung by a bee refuses black-and-yellow striped insects afterwards.
- Law of effect (Thorndike): a response followed by a satisfying outcome is strengthened; one followed by an unpleasant outcome is weakened.
- Operant conditioning: Action (operant) → Consequence (reinforcement or punishment) → change in frequency of the action.
Insight learning and imitation
Insight learning is the highest form of learning. The animal solves a new problem suddenly, by grasping the relationship between the parts of the situation, without going through random trial and error. It seems to think the problem out, and once the solution is found it is remembered and used again at once.
The classic experiments were done by the German psychologist Wolfgang Kohler with chimpanzees between 1913 and 1917. A chimpanzee named Sultan was kept in a cage with a bunch of bananas hung from the roof, too high to reach, and a few wooden boxes lying about. After some jumping and failed attempts Sultan sat and looked, then suddenly dragged a box under the bananas, climbed on it and took them. Later, with the fruit higher still, he stacked two and then three boxes. In another test bananas were placed outside the cage beyond arm's reach, with two hollow bamboo sticks inside, each too short. After a long pause Sultan pushed the thinner stick into the end of the thicker one, making a long stick, and raked in the fruit. The solution came all at once, after a period of apparent thought, not after hundreds of random tries.
Insight learning needs a large, well-developed cerebrum, and it is found mainly in primates, elephants, dolphins and some birds such as crows and parrots. A New Caledonian crow bends a piece of wire into a hook to lift a bucket of food from a tube. Sea otters use stones as anvils to crack shellfish. Human beings show insight constantly, whenever we say "Aha!" and see how to solve a puzzle. Insight uses past experience: Sultan could join the sticks because he had earlier played with sticks and boxes; but he combined those experiences in a new way for a new problem.
Imitation (observational learning) is learning by watching and copying another animal, usually a parent or an older member of the group. Young chimpanzees learn termite fishing and nut cracking by watching adults for years. In 1953 on Koshima Island in Japan a young macaque named Imo began washing sand off sweet potatoes in a stream; within a few years most of the troop had copied her, and the habit is still passed on today. Blue tits in England learned from each other to peck open the foil caps of milk bottles left on doorsteps. Song birds learn their song by imitating adult males. Human children learn language, gestures and skills largely by imitation, and the spread of a learned habit through a group by imitation is the beginning of culture.
These higher forms of learning give animals a great advantage: a new solution found by one individual can spread to the whole group without waiting for evolution to build it into the genes.
- Sultan the chimpanzee joining two short sticks to reach bananas outside the cage, after a pause for 'thought'.
- Imo the Japanese macaque washing sweet potatoes, a habit copied by the whole troop within a few years.
- Blue tits learning from one another to open milk-bottle caps, a habit that spread across Britain in the 1920s and 1930s.
- Insight learning = sudden solution of a new problem by understanding relationships, without trial and error; requires a well-developed cerebrum.
- Imitation = learning by observing and copying another individual; the basis of animal 'culture'.
Social behaviour: living in groups
Many animals live not alone but in groups: a herd of deer, a flock of parakeets, a school of sardines, a troop of langurs, a pack of wild dogs, a colony of honeybees, a termite mound holding a million individuals. Social behaviour is the behaviour of animals towards other members of their own species, and includes cooperation, communication, division of labour, dominance and submission, mutual defence and care of the young.
Group living has clear advantages. Protection: many eyes spot a predator sooner; a herd of chital feeding with langurs overhead benefits from the langurs' alarm calls. A flock of starlings wheeling together confuses a hawk. Musk oxen form a ring with horns outward around their calves. Finding food: pelicans drive fish into shallow water together; wild dogs and lions hunt cooperatively and can bring down prey far larger than themselves. Division of labour: in bee, ant and termite colonies different individuals do different jobs. Care of young: in elephant herds all the females guard and help every calf. Warmth: emperor penguins huddle through the Antarctic winter, taking turns on the cold outer edge. Group living also has costs: more competition for food and mates, and faster spread of disease and parasites.
Social groups are usually organised by a dominance hierarchy or pecking order. In a flock of hens, hen A can peck every other hen, hen B can peck all but A, and so on down to the lowest hen, which is pecked by all. Once the order is settled by a few early fights, each hen knows her place, fighting stops, and the group feeds peacefully. Wolves, baboons and langurs have similar ranks, with a dominant (alpha) male or female who eats first and mates most. Rank is shown by posture: a dominant wolf stands tall with raised tail, a submissive one crouches, lowers its tail and rolls over.
The most highly organised societies are those of social insects. A honeybee colony has one queen, the only fertile female, who lays up to 2,000 eggs a day; a few hundred drones, males whose only work is to mate with a new queen; and 20,000 to 60,000 workers, sterile females who do every other task. A worker's duties change with age: cleaning cells, feeding larvae with royal jelly, building comb, guarding the entrance, and finally foraging for nectar and pollen. A termite colony adds a king and soldiers with huge jaws. In these colonies individuals are so dependent on one another that the colony behaves like a single organism.
Social behaviour is also seen in the altruism of some animals, where one individual takes a risk for others: a ground squirrel gives an alarm call that may attract the predator to itself; a worker bee dies when it stings a raider. Such behaviour spreads because the individuals helped are close relatives who share the same genes.
- Chital and langurs feeding together in Indian forests: the langurs' alarm calls warn the deer of a tiger.
- A hen-house pecking order: after a few days of squabbles a stable rank is fixed and fighting stops.
- A honeybee colony: one queen, a few hundred drones, tens of thousands of workers whose jobs change with age.
- Social behaviour = interactions between members of the same species: cooperation, communication, dominance, division of labour, parental care.
- Honeybee castes: Queen (fertile female, lays eggs) · Drone (male, mates) · Worker (sterile female, all other work).
Communication in animals: the dance language of honeybees
Communication is the passing of information from one animal to another by signals that change the receiver's behaviour. Animals communicate by sound (bird song, the alarm bark of a langur, the roar of a tiger, the croak of frogs in the rains, the chirp of crickets), by sight (the peacock's tail, the firefly's flashes, the raised hackles of a dog, the colour of a chameleon), by smell (a dog marking a lamp post with urine, a female moth releasing a scent that a male can detect kilometres away, the trail an ant lays to food), by touch (grooming in monkeys, the nuzzling of a cow and calf) and even by electricity in some fishes. Chemical signals that pass between members of a species are called pheromones; the queen bee's pheromone keeps the workers sterile and united, and the alarm pheromone released by a stinging bee brings others to attack.
The most remarkable communication known in insects is the dance language of the honeybee, decoded by the Austrian scientist Karl von Frisch in the 1940s. When a forager bee finds a rich source of nectar she returns to the hive and dances on the vertical face of the comb, surrounded by other workers who touch her with their antennae and taste the nectar she carries.
If the food is near the hive, within about 50 to 100 metres, she performs the round dance: she runs in a small circle, turns and runs in a circle the other way, again and again. This says only "there is food close by" and the flower's scent on her body tells which flower to seek.
If the food is farther away, she performs the waggle dance, shaped like a figure of eight. She runs a short straight line while waggling her abdomen from side to side, circles back to the start, runs the straight line again, and circles back on the other side. This dance carries three pieces of information. Distance: the farther the food, the slower the dance and the longer the waggle run; a rate of about ten straight runs in 15 seconds means roughly 100 metres, and two runs means about 6 kilometres. Direction: the angle between the straight waggle run and the vertical on the comb equals the angle between the sun and the food source as seen from the hive. A waggle run straight up means "fly towards the sun"; straight down means "fly away from the sun"; 60 degrees to the right of vertical means "fly 60 degrees to the right of the sun". Richness: the more vigorous and longer the dancing, the better the food. Bees also correct the direction as the sun moves across the sky.
Von Frisch proved all this by placing dishes of sugar water at known distances and directions, marking the foragers with paint, and watching the dances through a glass-sided hive. He also showed that bees see colours (but not red) and ultraviolet, and can use polarised light to find the sun's position on cloudy days. For decoding this "language" he shared the 1973 Nobel Prize.
- A forager returning from flowers 40 metres away performs the round dance; her hive-mates search nearby for flowers with the scent she carries.
- Food 1 kilometre away at 90 degrees to the left of the sun: the waggle run points 90 degrees to the left of vertical on the comb, at a slow tempo.
- A female silk moth's pheromone is detected by a male's feathery antennae from several kilometres downwind.
- Round dance = food within about 50-100 m; gives no direction.
- Waggle dance: angle of waggle run from vertical = angle of food from the sun; slower dance and longer waggle run = greater distance.
- Pheromone = a chemical released by one animal that changes the behaviour of others of the same species.
Courtship and territorial behaviour
Courtship is the special behaviour that animals show before mating to attract and win a mate of the correct species, to signal readiness, and to reduce aggression between the partners. It is mostly innate, and each species has its own display, so that it also prevents mating between different species.
The peacock is India's classic example. In the breeding season, with the first rains, the male spreads his enormous train of eye-spotted feathers into a fan, quivers it with a rattling sound and struts before the peahen, turning to show every angle. The peahen chooses the male with the largest and most perfect train; studies show that peahens prefer males with more eye-spots, which indicate good health. The sarus crane, seen in the fields of Andhra Pradesh and north India, performs a dance in which the pair bow, leap into the air with wings spread, and call together with necks raised; the pair mate for life and dance every season. Male frogs and toads croak in chorus after the rains, each species with its own call, and females move to the loudest callers. Fireflies flash in a species-specific pattern. Male fiddler crabs wave one huge claw. Sticklebacks perform the zigzag dance, and bower birds of Australia build decorated arbours of twigs and blue objects that serve only to impress females. In many species males fight or display against each other, as stags lock antlers and blackbucks spar with their spiral horns, and the winner mates.
Courtship serves several purposes: it brings male and female of the same species together at the right time, it synchronises their readiness so that eggs and sperm are released together, it allows the female to choose the healthiest partner, and it calms the natural fear or aggression between two animals coming close.
Territorial behaviour is the defence of an area, the territory, against other members of the same species. The territory may hold the animal's food supply, its nest site, or its mates. A male robin sings from a perch to announce that a patch of garden is his; if another male enters, the owner sings louder, displays his red breast, and finally attacks. A tiger marks the boundary of a territory of 20 to 100 square kilometres by spraying urine on trees and scratching bark, and other tigers read these marks and keep away. Male lizards do push-ups and show their coloured throat fans; dogs mark lamp posts; a pair of Indian robins drives other robins from the yard where they nest. Territories are usually defended by signals such as song, scent and display rather than by actual fighting, which saves energy and injury. Territorial behaviour spaces animals out so that each has enough food, and it reduces the crowding that spreads disease.
Both courtship and territory are strongly controlled by hormones. In birds the growth of the testes in spring, triggered by longer days, raises testosterone, and this starts singing, display and territorial fighting; when the season ends the hormones fall and the behaviour stops.
- The peacock's train display at the onset of the monsoon; peahens choose the male with the most eye-spots.
- A pair of sarus cranes dancing and calling in unison in a wet field in the breeding season.
- A tiger spraying urine on trees along the edge of its range so that neighbouring tigers keep to their own territories.
- Courtship = species-specific pre-mating behaviour that attracts a mate, ensures the correct species, synchronises the pair and reduces aggression.
- Territory = an area defended by an individual or group against members of the same species, usually by signals rather than fighting.
Migration and other seasonal behaviour
Migration is the regular, seasonal, long-distance movement of animals from one region to another and back, usually to escape harsh weather or scarce food and to reach good breeding grounds. It is largely innate: many young birds migrate correctly on their first journey without adults. It is triggered by changes in day length that alter hormone levels and drive the animal to eat heavily, store fat and grow restless.
Birds are the greatest migrants. Every winter the wetlands of Andhra Pradesh, such as Kolleru and Pulicat lakes, fill with ducks, teals, pintails, flamingos, pelicans and waders that have flown from Siberia, Central Asia and the Himalaya to escape the northern winter, returning north in March to breed. The Siberian crane once flew to Bharatpur in Rajasthan. The Arctic tern holds the record, flying from the Arctic to the Antarctic and back every year, about 35,000 kilometres. The bar-headed goose crosses the Himalaya at over 7,000 metres on its way to Indian lakes. Amur falcons pass through Nagaland each autumn on their way from Siberia to Africa.
Mammals also migrate: wildebeest cross the Serengeti in vast herds following the rains; humpback whales swim from polar feeding waters to tropical calving grounds; fruit bats move with the fruiting of trees. Among fishes, hilsa swim up the rivers of Bengal and Andhra to spawn, salmon return from the sea to the stream of their birth, and the European eel crosses the Atlantic to breed. The olive ridley turtle comes ashore in tens of thousands on the Odisha coast in a mass nesting called arribada. Insects migrate too: monarch butterflies travel 4,000 kilometres from Canada to Mexico, and swarms of desert locusts cross the Arabian Sea into Rajasthan and Gujarat.
How do migrants find their way? Experiments with caged birds and with birds carried far from home show that they use several compasses: the position of the sun by day, corrected for time with an internal clock; the pattern of stars around the pole star at night; the Earth's magnetic field, sensed by tiny magnetic particles or by special molecules in the eye; and, near home, familiar landmarks such as coastlines and rivers, smells, and low-frequency sounds. Homing pigeons released hundreds of kilometres away return to their loft using the same abilities.
Other seasonal behaviours are hibernation, the deep winter sleep of bears, hedgehogs and many frogs and snakes, in which body temperature, heartbeat and breathing fall very low and the animal lives on stored fat; and aestivation, the summer dormancy of the Indian lungfish, land snails and some frogs, which bury themselves in mud or seal their shells to survive heat and drought until the rains return. Both are innate responses to unfavourable seasons, triggered by temperature and day length, and both conserve energy when food is unavailable.
- Pintails and shovelers arriving at Kolleru Lake in November from Siberia and leaving in March.
- The Arctic tern's yearly round trip of about 35,000 km between the Arctic and Antarctic.
- Olive ridley turtles nesting in their thousands at Gahirmatha beach, Odisha, each female returning to the beach where she hatched.
- Migration = regular seasonal two-way movement of animals between regions, triggered by day length and hormones.
- Navigation cues: sun compass + star compass + magnetic sense + landmarks, smells and sounds.
- Hibernation = winter dormancy; aestivation = summer dormancy; both lower metabolism to survive scarcity.
Parental care and breeding behaviour
Parental care is any behaviour of a parent that increases the survival of its offspring after the eggs are laid or the young are born. It ranges from none at all to years of devoted attention, and the amount of care is matched to the number of young: animals that give no care produce enormous numbers of eggs, while those that give much care produce few.
Most fishes, frogs and insects lay hundreds or thousands of eggs and leave them. A female cod lays millions of eggs of which perhaps two survive. Yet some show remarkable care. The male stickleback builds a nest, fans the eggs with his fins to keep them oxygenated and guards the fry. The male seahorse carries the eggs in a pouch. The mouth-brooding tilapia keeps its eggs and young in its mouth. The female scorpion carries her young on her back. Some frogs carry tadpoles on their backs or in their vocal sacs, and the male midwife toad wraps the egg strings round his legs. Crocodiles guard the nest, help the hatchlings out of the eggs and carry them to water in their jaws.
Birds show elaborate breeding behaviour. The sequence in a typical Indian garden bird such as the red-vented bulbul is: establishing a territory, courtship, choosing a nest site, building the nest, laying, incubating the eggs (keeping them warm with the brood patch of bare skin), feeding the nestlings, removing their droppings, defending them from crows and cats, and teaching the fledglings to fly and feed. Both parents usually share the work. Nests vary from the weaver's hanging basket and the tailor bird's leaf sewn with cobweb, to the hornbill's tree hole in which the female is sealed with mud by the male, who feeds her through a slit for weeks. Ground-nesting birds like the lapwing pretend to have a broken wing to lure a predator away from the chicks. Brood parasites such as the koel and cuckoo lay eggs in the nests of crows and babblers and let the hosts do all the work.
Mammals give the most care because the young are born helpless and depend on milk. The mother suckles, cleans, warms and protects them, and in social species the whole group helps: elephant calves are guarded by all the cows of the herd, and lion cubs are nursed by any lactating female. Care continues long after weaning as the young learn hunting or foraging by watching adults. Chimpanzee and elephant young stay with their mothers for years, and human children longest of all.
Parental care is innate in its basics, released by hormones such as prolactin (which causes milk secretion and broodiness) and oxytocin, and by sign stimuli from the young: the gaping red mouth of a nestling releases feeding, the cry of a lamb releases the ewe's search. Yet in mammals experience matters too; a first-time mother often handles her young more clumsily than an experienced one.
- A male stickleback fanning water over his eggs and chasing away any fish that approaches the nest.
- A female hornbill sealed inside a tree hole for weeks while the male passes fruit through a narrow slit.
- A lapwing dragging a wing as if broken to draw a jackal away from its chicks, then flying off once the danger is far from the nest.
- Rule of parental care: more care per offspring ↔ fewer offspring produced (fish: thousands of eggs, no care; mammals: few young, prolonged care).
- Hormones of parental behaviour: prolactin (milk, broodiness) and oxytocin (birth, milk let-down, bonding).
Biological basis of behaviour: nerves, hormones and environment
Behaviour does not happen by magic. Every act, from a reflex blink to a peacock's display, is produced by the body's nervous system and endocrine system working together, and it is shaped by the environment in which the animal lives.
The nervous system gives the fast responses. Sense organs detect stimuli; sensory nerves carry impulses to the spinal cord and brain; the brain compares them with stored memories and the animal's present needs and sends impulses along motor nerves to muscles. The more complex the brain, especially the cerebral cortex, the more flexible and learned the behaviour. A cockroach with a tiny brain behaves mostly by reflex and taxis; a dog with a large cerebrum can learn dozens of commands; a chimpanzee can solve problems by insight.
The hormones give the slower, longer-lasting readiness or drive. Testosterone in male birds and mammals in the breeding season brings on song, display, territorial fighting and mating; when the season ends and the hormone falls, the same birds live peacefully in mixed flocks. Oestrogen and progesterone prepare the female for mating and for nest building, and prolactin makes her broody. Adrenaline, released in danger, prepares the body to fight or flee. Thyroid hormone controls the level of activity and the moult of feathers. Melatonin, released in darkness, sets the daily and seasonal clocks and so triggers migration and hibernation. Pheromones, secreted outside the body, act as hormones between individuals.
Behaviour follows biological rhythms. Most animals have a daily (circadian) rhythm of about 24 hours: diurnal animals like squirrels and most birds are active by day, nocturnal ones like owls, bats and moths by night, crepuscular ones like rabbits and nightjars at dawn and dusk. The rhythm is set by an internal clock in the brain and adjusted daily by sunlight. There are also lunar rhythms (the arribada of turtles and the spawning of corals follow the moon), tidal rhythms in shore animals, and annual rhythms of breeding, moult and migration.
The environment shapes behaviour in two ways. Over the animal's lifetime it provides the experiences from which learning builds; a rat reared in a rich cage with toys develops a heavier cerebral cortex and learns faster than one reared in a bare cage. Over generations it selects the innate behaviours that survive best: desert animals are nocturnal to avoid heat, arctic animals hibernate, island birds that never met predators lose their fear and are easily wiped out when cats arrive. Behaviour is therefore always the product of heredity (genes) and environment (experience) together, never one alone.
Finally, behaviour is affected by internal state. A hungry animal searches for food and ignores a mate; a satisfied one does the reverse. Illness, fatigue, age and stress all change behaviour, which is why a good farmer or veterinarian watches an animal's behaviour as the first sign of disease.
- A male bulbul that sings and fights in March lives quietly in a flock in October: the difference is testosterone.
- A rat reared in an enriched cage learns a maze faster than one reared in a bare cage: environment shapes the brain.
- Owls hunting at night and squirrels feeding by day: opposite circadian rhythms in the same forest.
- Behaviour = Heredity (genes, innate patterns) + Environment (experience, learning) + Internal state (hormones, hunger, fatigue).
- Circadian rhythm = an internal daily cycle of about 24 hours, reset each day by light.
Human behaviour and the value of studying animal behaviour
Human beings share the basic machinery of behaviour with other animals. We have reflexes: the knee jerk, the blink, the sneeze, the sucking and grasping of a newborn. We have a few inborn drives: hunger, thirst, fear of sudden loud sounds and of falling, the urge to sleep, and the need for company. We show habituation when we stop hearing the ceiling fan, classical conditioning when our mouth waters at the sight of tamarind, operant conditioning when a child repeats what earns praise, and imitation when a toddler copies the way a parent speaks. Our daily rhythm of sleep and waking is a circadian rhythm like that of any other animal, and jet lag is what happens when it is disturbed.
But human behaviour differs from that of every other animal in degree so great that it becomes a difference in kind. The human cerebral cortex is far larger in proportion to the body, and so learning, memory, insight and reasoning dominate. We have language, a system of arbitrary symbols that can describe things absent, past or imaginary, which no honeybee dance or chimpanzee gesture can do. We pass knowledge across generations by teaching, writing and now electronic media, so that culture accumulates: a child today inherits the discoveries of thousands of years. We can plan far ahead, foresee consequences and choose to act against our immediate drives, which is the basis of self-control and moral behaviour. Even our few instincts are heavily modified by upbringing: what people fear, eat, and find attractive varies enormously between cultures.
Human behaviour is shaped by heredity and environment together, exactly as in animals. Studies of twins show that temperament has a genetic component, while the family, school, friends and society provide the experiences that build personality. Hormones affect us too: adrenaline in fear, the changes of adolescence, and the daily cycle of melatonin.
Why study animal behaviour at all? It has many practical uses. In agriculture and animal husbandry, knowing the feeding, breeding and social habits of cattle, poultry and fish improves their health and yield: hens lay more when kept in stable groups, and fish are bred by imitating the water conditions that trigger spawning. In pest control, the pheromone traps used in cotton and mango orchards attract male insects and stop them breeding, avoiding poisonous sprays. In wildlife conservation, knowledge of migration routes protects the wetlands and corridors that elephants, turtles and cranes depend on, and knowledge of imprinting lets us rear endangered birds without spoiling them. In medicine and psychology, conditioning is used to treat phobias and addiction, and animal studies of learning underlie modern teaching methods. In animal welfare, understanding that animals feel fear and need company has changed how zoos, farms and laboratories are run. And in everyday life, knowing how a dog reads our posture or why a cow kicks makes us safer and kinder.
The message of this chapter is that behaviour, like structure, is a product of evolution, that innate and learned behaviour together let animals survive in a changing world, and that we ourselves are part of that story.
- A newborn baby's grasp reflex is so strong that it can support its own weight briefly, and it disappears by about six months as the brain matures.
- Pheromone traps in a cotton field catch male pink bollworm moths, so fewer females are fertilised and fewer larvae attack the bolls.
- Treating a fear of dogs by gradual, safe exposure to friendly dogs uses the principle of extinction of a conditioned response.
- Human behaviour = the same innate base as other mammals (reflexes, drives, rhythms) + a vastly greater share of learned, cultural and reasoned behaviour.
Key Concepts
- Behaviour
- The response of an organism to stimuli from inside its body or from its environment, coordinated by the nervous system and hormones.
- Ethology
- The scientific study of animal behaviour, especially under natural conditions, founded by Lorenz, Tinbergen and von Frisch.
- Stimulus and response
- A stimulus is a detectable change in the environment or body, and a response is the action the animal makes to it.
- Innate behaviour
- Inborn, inherited, stereotyped and species-specific behaviour performed correctly without prior experience, such as web spinning.
- Reflex action
- A rapid, involuntary, automatic and usually protective response of a part of the body, carried through a reflex arc without a decision by the brain.
- Reflex arc
- The pathway of a reflex: receptor, sensory neuron, spinal cord relay neuron, motor neuron and effector.
- Taxis
- A directed movement of the whole animal towards (positive) or away from (negative) a stimulus such as light, chemicals or gravity.
- Instinct
- A complex inherited chain of actions, such as nest building or courtship, released by a sign stimulus when the animal is in the right internal state.
- Sign stimulus (releaser)
- A simple feature of the environment, such as the red spot on a herring gull's beak, that triggers a fixed innate response.
- Learned behaviour
- Behaviour acquired or modified through experience, variable between individuals and requiring memory and practice.
- Habituation
- The simplest learning, in which an animal stops responding to a repeated stimulus that is neither harmful nor rewarding.
- Imprinting
- Rapid, lasting learning during a brief sensitive period early in life, by which young geese follow the first moving object they see, as Lorenz showed.
- Classical conditioning
- Learning in which a neutral stimulus such as a bell, repeatedly paired with food, comes to evoke the reflex response of salivation, as in Pavlov's dogs.
- Trial-and-error learning
- Learning in which random actions that bring a reward are repeated and unsuccessful ones dropped, as in Thorndike's cats in a puzzle box.
- Insight learning
- Solving a new problem suddenly by understanding the relationships in a situation, as Kohler's chimpanzee did by stacking boxes to reach bananas.
- Imitation
- Learning by observing and copying another individual, the basis of the spread of habits such as potato washing among Japanese macaques.
- Social behaviour
- The interactions between members of the same species, including cooperation, dominance hierarchies, division of labour and communication.
- Waggle dance
- The figure-of-eight dance of a honeybee forager whose angle from the vertical gives the direction of food relative to the sun and whose tempo gives the distance.
- Pheromone
- A chemical released by an animal into the environment that changes the behaviour of other members of its species.
- Migration
- Regular seasonal long-distance movement of animals between regions, guided by the sun, stars, magnetic field and landmarks.
End-of-Chapter Trial Paper & Test Questions
Topic-wise questions to test your understanding of every concept in this chapter.
-
What is behaviour? Define ethology and name the three scientists who shared the Nobel Prize in 1973 for their work on animal behaviour. / व्यवहार क्या है? आचारशास्त्र (एथोलॉजी) की परिभाषा दीजिए और उन तीन वैज्ञानिकों के नाम बताइए जिन्हें पशु व्यवहार पर कार्य के लिए 1973 में नोबेल पुरस्कार मिला।
Show answer
Behaviour is the response of an organism to a stimulus from within its body or from its surroundings, coordinated by the nervous system and hormones; a dog wagging its tail or a snail withdrawing when touched are examples. Ethology is the scientific study of animal behaviour, especially of animals in their natural surroundings. The 1973 Nobel Prize was shared by Konrad Lorenz (imprinting in geese), Niko Tinbergen (sign stimuli in gulls and sticklebacks) and Karl von Frisch (the dance language of honeybees). / व्यवहार किसी जीव द्वारा अपने शरीर के भीतर या परिवेश से आए उद्दीपन के प्रति दी गई प्रतिक्रिया है, जिसका समन्वय तंत्रिका तंत्र और हार्मोन करते हैं; कुत्ते का पूँछ हिलाना या छूने पर घोंघे का सिकुड़ जाना इसके उदाहरण हैं। आचारशास्त्र (एथोलॉजी) पशु व्यवहार का, विशेषकर प्राकृतिक परिवेश में, वैज्ञानिक अध्ययन है। 1973 का नोबेल पुरस्कार कोनराड लोरेंज़ (हंसों में छापन), निको टिनबर्गन (गल और स्टिकलबैक में संकेत उद्दीपन) और कार्ल फॉन फ्रिश (मधुमक्खियों की नृत्य भाषा) को संयुक्त रूप से मिला।
-
Distinguish between innate behaviour and learned behaviour with two examples of each. / सहज (जन्मजात) व्यवहार और अर्जित (सीखे हुए) व्यवहार में अंतर स्पष्ट कीजिए, प्रत्येक के दो उदाहरण दीजिए।
Show answer
Innate behaviour is inherited through genes, appears correctly the first time without practice, is stereotyped and the same in every member of the species: a spider spinning its web and a newborn baby sucking are examples. Learned behaviour is acquired through experience, is not present at birth, varies between individuals and improves with practice: a dog coming when its name is called and a child learning to ride a bicycle are examples. Innate behaviour is reliable but rigid; learned behaviour is flexible but takes time and needs a developed brain. / सहज व्यवहार जीन द्वारा वंशागत होता है, बिना अभ्यास के पहली बार ही सही ढंग से प्रकट होता है, रूढ़िबद्ध होता है और प्रजाति के हर सदस्य में एक जैसा होता है; मकड़ी का जाला बुनना और नवजात शिशु का चूसना इसके उदाहरण हैं। अर्जित व्यवहार अनुभव से प्राप्त होता है, जन्म के समय नहीं होता, व्यक्तियों में भिन्न होता है और अभ्यास से सुधरता है; नाम पुकारने पर कुत्ते का आना और बच्चे का साइकिल चलाना सीखना इसके उदाहरण हैं। सहज व्यवहार विश्वसनीय पर कठोर होता है; अर्जित व्यवहार लचीला होता है पर समय और विकसित मस्तिष्क माँगता है।
-
What is a reflex action? Describe the reflex arc with a labelled diagram, taking the example of withdrawing the hand from a hot object. / प्रतिवर्ती क्रिया क्या है? गर्म वस्तु से हाथ हटाने के उदाहरण द्वारा प्रतिवर्ती चाप का नामांकित चित्र सहित वर्णन कीजिए।
Show answer
A reflex action is a rapid, involuntary, automatic and usually protective response to a stimulus, made without a decision by the brain. When a finger touches a hot pan, heat receptors in the skin generate an impulse; a sensory neuron carries it to the spinal cord; there a relay neuron in the grey matter passes it to a motor neuron; the motor neuron carries it to the biceps muscle, which contracts and pulls the hand away. This pathway, receptor to sensory neuron to spinal cord to motor neuron to effector, is the reflex arc. Only afterwards does a message reach the brain and we feel the pain. The diagram should show the hand and flame, the sensory neuron entering the dorsal side of the spinal cord, the relay neuron, and the motor neuron leaving the ventral side to the muscle. / प्रतिवर्ती क्रिया किसी उद्दीपन के प्रति तीव्र, अनैच्छिक, स्वचालित और प्रायः सुरक्षात्मक प्रतिक्रिया है, जो मस्तिष्क के निर्णय के बिना होती है। जब उँगली गर्म तवे को छूती है तो त्वचा के ताप ग्राही आवेग उत्पन्न करते हैं; संवेदी न्यूरॉन उसे मेरुरज्जु तक ले जाता है; वहाँ धूसर द्रव्य में स्थित रिले न्यूरॉन उसे प्रेरक न्यूरॉन को देता है; प्रेरक न्यूरॉन उसे बाइसेप्स पेशी तक पहुँचाता है जो सिकुड़कर हाथ को हटा देती है। ग्राही से संवेदी न्यूरॉन, मेरुरज्जु, प्रेरक न्यूरॉन और प्रभावक तक का यह मार्ग प्रतिवर्ती चाप कहलाता है। इसके बाद ही संदेश मस्तिष्क तक पहुँचता है और हमें दर्द महसूस होता है। चित्र में हाथ और लौ, मेरुरज्जु के पृष्ठ भाग में प्रवेश करता संवेदी न्यूरॉन, रिले न्यूरॉन और अधर भाग से पेशी तक जाता प्रेरक न्यूरॉन दिखाइए।
-
Describe Pavlov's experiment on conditioning in dogs. What are the conditioned and unconditioned stimuli in it? / कुत्तों में अनुबंधन पर पावलव के प्रयोग का वर्णन कीजिए। इसमें अनुबंधित और अननुबंधित उद्दीपन कौन से हैं?
Show answer
Pavlov fitted a tube to a dog's cheek to measure saliva. Food placed in the mouth naturally caused salivation: food is the unconditioned stimulus and salivation the unconditioned response. He then rang a bell just before giving food and repeated the pairing many times. At first the bell alone produced no saliva, but after repeated pairings the dog salivated on hearing the bell even without food. The bell had become the conditioned stimulus and salivation to the bell the conditioned response. If the bell was rung many times without food the response faded, which is extinction. The experiment showed that a reflex can be attached to a new stimulus by association, the basis of classical conditioning. / पावलव ने कुत्ते के गाल में एक नली लगाई ताकि लार मापी जा सके। मुँह में भोजन रखने पर स्वाभाविक रूप से लार निकली: भोजन अननुबंधित उद्दीपन है और लार निकलना अननुबंधित प्रतिक्रिया। फिर उन्होंने भोजन देने से ठीक पहले घंटी बजाई और यह जोड़ी कई बार दोहराई। पहले अकेली घंटी से लार नहीं निकली, पर बार-बार जोड़ने के बाद बिना भोजन के भी घंटी सुनते ही कुत्ता लार टपकाने लगा। घंटी अनुबंधित उद्दीपन बन गई और घंटी पर लार निकलना अनुबंधित प्रतिक्रिया। यदि घंटी बिना भोजन के बार-बार बजाई जाए तो प्रतिक्रिया मिटने लगती है, जिसे विलोपन कहते हैं। प्रयोग ने दिखाया कि साहचर्य से किसी प्रतिवर्त को नए उद्दीपन से जोड़ा जा सकता है, यही क्लासिकी अनुबंधन का आधार है।
-
What is imprinting? Explain Lorenz's experiment with goslings and state the survival value of imprinting. / छापन (इम्प्रिंटिंग) क्या है? हंस के बच्चों पर लोरेंज़ के प्रयोग को समझाइए और छापन का उत्तरजीविता में महत्व बताइए।
Show answer
Imprinting is a rapid and almost irreversible form of learning that occurs during a short sensitive period early in life, in which a young animal learns to recognise and follow its parent. Lorenz divided greylag goose eggs into two groups: one hatched under the mother and the goslings followed her; the other hatched in an incubator and the goslings saw Lorenz first, so they followed him everywhere, even ignoring their real mother, and when the groups were mixed each ran back to its own 'parent'. Imprinting occurs only in the first day or two, needs only brief exposure and lasts for life. Its survival value is that it keeps chicks close to the mother who protects and feeds them (filial imprinting) and later ensures they choose a mate of their own species (sexual imprinting). / छापन शीघ्र और लगभग अपरिवर्तनीय अधिगम का एक रूप है, जो जीवन के आरंभ में एक छोटी संवेदनशील अवधि में होता है और जिसमें शिशु प्राणी अपने माता-पिता को पहचानना और उनका अनुसरण करना सीखता है। लोरेंज़ ने ग्रेलैग हंस के अंडों को दो समूहों में बाँटा: एक समूह माँ के नीचे फूटा और बच्चे उसके पीछे चले; दूसरा इनक्यूबेटर में फूटा और बच्चों ने सबसे पहले लोरेंज़ को देखा, इसलिए वे हर जगह उनके पीछे चलते रहे, अपनी असली माँ को भी अनदेखा करते हुए, और समूहों को मिलाने पर हर समूह अपने 'माता-पिता' के पास लौट गया। छापन केवल पहले एक-दो दिनों में होता है, थोड़ी देर के संपर्क से हो जाता है और जीवन भर रहता है। इसका महत्व यह है कि यह बच्चों को रक्षा और भोजन देने वाली माँ के पास रखता है (संतति छापन) और बाद में अपनी ही प्रजाति का साथी चुनना सुनिश्चित करता है (लैंगिक छापन)।
-
How does a honeybee communicate the distance and direction of a food source to other bees? Describe the round dance and the waggle dance. / मधुमक्खी भोजन स्रोत की दूरी और दिशा अन्य मक्खियों को कैसे बताती है? वृत्त नृत्य और वैगल नृत्य का वर्णन कीजिए।
Show answer
A forager returning from food dances on the vertical comb while other workers touch her and taste her nectar. If the food is within about 50 to 100 metres she performs the round dance, running in small circles alternately clockwise and anticlockwise; this tells only that food is near, and the flower scent on her body tells which flower. If the food is farther she performs the waggle dance, a figure of eight with a straight waggling run in the middle. The angle of the straight run from the vertical equals the angle of the food from the sun as seen from the hive, so a run straight up means fly towards the sun. The tempo gives distance: the farther the food, the slower the dance and the longer the waggle run. Vigorous, prolonged dancing signals rich food. Karl von Frisch decoded this using marked bees and dishes of sugar water at known positions. / भोजन से लौटी श्रमिक मक्खी ऊर्ध्वाधर छत्ते पर नाचती है, जबकि अन्य श्रमिक उसे छूती हैं और उसका मधु चखती हैं। यदि भोजन लगभग 50 से 100 मीटर के भीतर हो तो वह वृत्त नृत्य करती है, बारी-बारी से दक्षिणावर्त और वामावर्त छोटे वृत्तों में दौड़ते हुए; यह केवल बताता है कि भोजन पास है, और उसके शरीर पर लगी फूल की गंध बताती है कि कौन सा फूल। यदि भोजन दूर हो तो वह वैगल नृत्य करती है, जो आठ के आकार का होता है और बीच में एक सीधी दौड़ होती है जिसमें वह उदर हिलाती है। सीधी दौड़ का ऊर्ध्वाधर से कोण छत्ते से देखे गए सूर्य और भोजन के बीच के कोण के बराबर होता है, अतः सीधे ऊपर की दौड़ का अर्थ है सूर्य की ओर उड़ो। गति दूरी बताती है: भोजन जितना दूर, नृत्य उतना धीमा और वैगल दौड़ उतनी लंबी। जोशीला और लंबा नृत्य समृद्ध भोजन का संकेत है। कार्ल फॉन फ्रिश ने चिह्नित मक्खियों और ज्ञात स्थानों पर रखे चीनी के घोल के प्यालों से इसे समझा।
-
Describe Kohler's experiment on insight learning in chimpanzees. How does insight learning differ from trial-and-error learning? / चिम्पैंज़ी में अंतर्दृष्टि अधिगम पर कोहलर के प्रयोग का वर्णन कीजिए। अंतर्दृष्टि अधिगम प्रयत्न-त्रुटि अधिगम से कैसे भिन्न है?
Show answer
Kohler kept a chimpanzee named Sultan in a cage with bananas hung out of reach and some boxes lying around. After a few failed jumps Sultan paused, looked, and then suddenly dragged a box under the fruit, climbed on it and took the bananas; later he stacked two or three boxes. When bananas were placed outside the cage with two short bamboo sticks inside, he fitted one stick into the other to make a long one and raked in the fruit. The solution appeared all at once after a period of apparent thought and was used immediately afterwards. In trial-and-error learning, as with Thorndike's cats, the animal tries many random actions and gradually keeps the successful one over many trials, so the improvement is slow and gradual; in insight learning the animal understands the relationship between the objects and solves the problem suddenly without random attempts, which needs a large cerebrum. / कोहलर ने सुल्तान नामक चिम्पैंज़ी को एक पिंजरे में रखा जिसमें केले पहुँच से ऊपर लटके थे और कुछ बक्से पड़े थे। कुछ असफल छलांगों के बाद सुल्तान रुका, देखा, और फिर अचानक एक बक्सा फल के नीचे खींचा, उस पर चढ़ा और केले ले लिए; बाद में उसने दो-तीन बक्से एक के ऊपर एक रखे। जब केले पिंजरे के बाहर रखे गए और भीतर बाँस की दो छोटी छड़ें थीं, तो उसने एक छड़ को दूसरी में फँसाकर लंबी छड़ बनाई और फल खींच लिए। समाधान स्पष्ट सोच की अवधि के बाद एक साथ प्रकट हुआ और तुरंत बाद उपयोग हुआ। प्रयत्न-त्रुटि अधिगम में, जैसे थॉर्नडाइक की बिल्लियों में, प्राणी कई यादृच्छिक क्रियाएँ करता है और अनेक प्रयासों में धीरे-धीरे सफल क्रिया को अपनाता है, अतः सुधार धीमा और क्रमिक होता है; अंतर्दृष्टि अधिगम में प्राणी वस्तुओं के संबंध को समझकर बिना यादृच्छिक प्रयासों के अचानक समस्या हल करता है, जिसके लिए बड़ा प्रमस्तिष्क चाहिए।
-
What is habituation? Give two examples and explain how it differs from fatigue. / अभ्यस्तीकरण (हैबिचुएशन) क्या है? दो उदाहरण दीजिए और बताइए कि यह थकान से कैसे भिन्न है।
Show answer
Habituation is the simplest form of learning, in which an animal gradually stops responding to a stimulus that is repeated many times and proves to be neither harmful nor rewarding. For example, a snail withdraws into its shell at the first tap on the water but stops withdrawing after several taps; birds that were frightened by a scarecrow soon perch on it. It saves the animal from wasting energy on meaningless stimuli. Habituation differs from fatigue because the response is not lost through tiredness of the muscles or sense organs: a new or different stimulus brings the full response back at once, and after a rest the original stimulus also works again. / अभ्यस्तीकरण अधिगम का सबसे सरल रूप है, जिसमें प्राणी बार-बार दोहराए गए ऐसे उद्दीपन पर प्रतिक्रिया देना धीरे-धीरे बंद कर देता है जो न हानिकारक हो न लाभदायक। उदाहरण के लिए, पानी पर पहली थपकी पर घोंघा खोल में सिकुड़ जाता है पर कई थपकियों के बाद सिकुड़ना बंद कर देता है; बिजूके से डरने वाले पक्षी जल्दी ही उस पर बैठने लगते हैं। यह प्राणी को निरर्थक उद्दीपनों पर ऊर्जा व्यर्थ करने से बचाता है। अभ्यस्तीकरण थकान से भिन्न है क्योंकि प्रतिक्रिया पेशियों या ज्ञानेंद्रियों की थकावट से नहीं खोती: नया या भिन्न उद्दीपन तुरंत पूरी प्रतिक्रिया लौटा देता है, और विश्राम के बाद मूल उद्दीपन भी फिर से काम करता है।
-
What are the advantages of living in groups? Explain the division of labour in a honeybee colony. / समूह में रहने के क्या लाभ हैं? मधुमक्खी कॉलोनी में श्रम विभाजन समझाइए।
Show answer
Group living gives protection because many eyes detect predators early and the group can defend itself together, as chital heed langur alarm calls and musk oxen form a ring around calves; it helps in finding and catching food, as when wild dogs hunt cooperatively; it allows division of labour; it gives shared care of the young, as in elephant herds; and it conserves warmth, as in huddling penguins. In a honeybee colony there are three castes. The single queen is the only fertile female and lays up to 2,000 eggs a day. A few hundred drones are males whose only work is to mate with a new queen. Tens of thousands of workers are sterile females who do all other work, changing jobs with age: cleaning cells, feeding larvae, building comb, guarding the entrance, and finally foraging for nectar and pollen. / समूह में रहने से सुरक्षा मिलती है क्योंकि अनेक आँखें शिकारी को जल्दी पहचान लेती हैं और समूह मिलकर रक्षा करता है, जैसे चीतल लंगूर की चेतावनी सुनते हैं और कस्तूरी बैल बछड़ों के चारों ओर घेरा बनाते हैं; भोजन खोजने और पकड़ने में मदद मिलती है, जैसे जंगली कुत्ते मिलकर शिकार करते हैं; श्रम विभाजन संभव होता है; बच्चों की साझा देखभाल होती है, जैसे हाथियों के झुंड में; और गर्मी बचती है, जैसे सटकर बैठे पेंगुइन में। मधुमक्खी कॉलोनी में तीन जातियाँ होती हैं। एकमात्र रानी ही उर्वर मादा है और प्रतिदिन 2,000 तक अंडे देती है। कुछ सौ ड्रोन नर हैं जिनका एकमात्र काम नई रानी से संगम करना है। हजारों श्रमिक बंध्य मादाएँ हैं जो बाकी सारा काम करती हैं और आयु के साथ काम बदलती हैं: कोष्ठ साफ करना, लार्वा को खिलाना, छत्ता बनाना, द्वार की रखवाली और अंत में मकरंद व पराग एकत्र करना।
-
What is migration? Name two migratory birds that visit Andhra Pradesh and explain how migrating birds find their way. / प्रवास क्या है? आंध्र प्रदेश में आने वाले दो प्रवासी पक्षियों के नाम बताइए और समझाइए कि प्रवासी पक्षी रास्ता कैसे खोजते हैं।
Show answer
Migration is the regular seasonal two-way movement of animals between regions to escape harsh weather or scarce food and to reach good breeding grounds; it is triggered by day length and hormones and is largely innate. Northern pintails, shovelers and other ducks, flamingos and pelicans from Siberia and Central Asia winter at Kolleru and Pulicat lakes in Andhra Pradesh and return north in March. Migrating birds navigate using the sun's position corrected by an internal clock during the day, the pattern of stars around the pole star at night, the Earth's magnetic field sensed by special cells, and near their destination familiar landmarks such as coastlines and rivers, smells and sounds. / प्रवास कठोर मौसम या भोजन की कमी से बचने और अच्छे प्रजनन स्थल तक पहुँचने के लिए प्राणियों की क्षेत्रों के बीच नियमित मौसमी दोतरफ़ा यात्रा है; यह दिन की लंबाई और हार्मोन से प्रेरित होता है और मुख्यतः सहज होता है। साइबेरिया और मध्य एशिया से उत्तरी पिनटेल, शॉवलर और अन्य बत्तखें, फ्लेमिंगो और पेलिकन आंध्र प्रदेश की कोल्लेरु और पुलिकट झीलों में सर्दी बिताते हैं और मार्च में उत्तर लौट जाते हैं। प्रवासी पक्षी दिन में आंतरिक घड़ी से संशोधित सूर्य की स्थिति, रात में ध्रुव तारे के चारों ओर तारों के पैटर्न, विशेष कोशिकाओं से अनुभूत पृथ्वी के चुंबकीय क्षेत्र, और गंतव्य के पास तटरेखा व नदियों जैसे परिचित स्थल-चिह्नों, गंधों और ध्वनियों से दिशा खोजते हैं।
-
Explain territorial behaviour and courtship behaviour with one Indian example of each. / क्षेत्रीय व्यवहार और प्रणय-निवेदन व्यवहार को एक-एक भारतीय उदाहरण सहित समझाइए।
Show answer
Territorial behaviour is the defence of an area containing food, nest sites or mates against other members of the same species, usually by signals such as song, scent marking and display rather than by fighting; it spaces animals out so that each has enough resources. A tiger marks its territory of 20 to 100 square kilometres by spraying urine on trees and scratching bark, and other tigers keep away. Courtship behaviour is the species-specific display before mating that attracts a mate of the right species, lets the female choose a healthy partner, synchronises the pair and reduces aggression between them. The peacock spreads and rattles its eye-spotted train before the peahen at the start of the monsoon, and the peahen chooses the male with the finest train. Both behaviours are controlled by breeding-season hormones. / क्षेत्रीय व्यवहार भोजन, घोंसले के स्थान या साथी वाले क्षेत्र की अपनी ही प्रजाति के अन्य सदस्यों से रक्षा है, जो प्रायः लड़ाई के बजाय गीत, गंध-चिह्न और प्रदर्शन जैसे संकेतों से होती है; यह प्राणियों को फैलाकर रखता है ताकि हर एक को पर्याप्त संसाधन मिलें। बाघ अपने 20 से 100 वर्ग किलोमीटर के क्षेत्र को पेड़ों पर मूत्र छिड़ककर और छाल खरोंचकर चिह्नित करता है, और अन्य बाघ दूर रहते हैं। प्रणय-निवेदन व्यवहार संगम से पहले का प्रजाति-विशिष्ट प्रदर्शन है जो सही प्रजाति के साथी को आकर्षित करता है, मादा को स्वस्थ साथी चुनने देता है, जोड़े को समकालिक करता है और उनके बीच आक्रामकता घटाता है। मोर मानसून के आरंभ में मोरनी के सामने अपने चंद्रक-युक्त पंखों को फैलाकर खड़खड़ाता है, और मोरनी सबसे सुंदर पंखों वाले नर को चुनती है। दोनों व्यवहार प्रजनन-ऋतु के हार्मोनों द्वारा नियंत्रित होते हैं।
-
How is the study of animal behaviour useful to human beings? Give four applications. / पशु व्यवहार का अध्ययन मनुष्य के लिए कैसे उपयोगी है? चार अनुप्रयोग दीजिए।
Show answer
First, in agriculture and animal husbandry, knowing the feeding, breeding and social habits of cattle, poultry and fish improves their health and yield; hens kept in stable groups lay more and fish are bred by imitating the conditions that trigger spawning. Second, in pest control, pheromone traps attract male insects such as the pink bollworm of cotton and stop them breeding without poisonous sprays. Third, in wildlife conservation, knowledge of migration routes protects the wetlands and corridors that cranes, turtles and elephants need, and knowledge of imprinting lets endangered birds be reared without becoming attached to humans. Fourth, in medicine and psychology, the principles of conditioning are used to treat phobias and addictions, and studies of animal learning underlie modern teaching and the training of guide dogs and sniffer dogs. / पहला, कृषि और पशुपालन में, मवेशियों, मुर्गियों और मछलियों की भोजन, प्रजनन और सामाजिक आदतों को जानने से उनका स्वास्थ्य और उत्पादन सुधरता है; स्थिर समूहों में रखी मुर्गियाँ अधिक अंडे देती हैं और अंडे देने को प्रेरित करने वाली परिस्थितियों की नकल करके मछलियों का प्रजनन कराया जाता है। दूसरा, कीट नियंत्रण में, फेरोमोन जाल कपास के गुलाबी सुंडी जैसे नर कीटों को आकर्षित कर बिना जहरीले छिड़काव के उनका प्रजनन रोकते हैं। तीसरा, वन्यजीव संरक्षण में, प्रवास मार्गों का ज्ञान उन आर्द्रभूमियों और गलियारों की रक्षा करता है जिनकी सारस, कछुओं और हाथियों को जरूरत है, और छापन का ज्ञान संकटग्रस्त पक्षियों को मनुष्यों से जुड़े बिना पालने देता है। चौथा, चिकित्सा और मनोविज्ञान में, अनुबंधन के सिद्धांत भय-रोग और व्यसन के उपचार में प्रयुक्त होते हैं, और पशु अधिगम के अध्ययन आधुनिक शिक्षण तथा मार्गदर्शक और सूँघने वाले कुत्तों के प्रशिक्षण का आधार हैं।
Related Laws & Principles
Explore allFoundational laws & principles behind this chapter. Each one opens a full page — what it says, why it matters, five practice questions and the mistakes to avoid.